Food wasn't the worst. Wasn't great either. .... The SERVICE however, oh, how the service was. They called our table last. Which is fine, someone has to go last. That, however, does not excuse NO ONE grabbing food and making us wait 20 minutes. Then, the table announcer lady had the AUDACITY to call US impatient. All for some tough steak and salad with no dressing. Never returning. I liked the lobby despite it's confusing design. 2 stars.

I had the most perfect wedding thanks to the staff at Otterkill. From the start Corey was extremely attentive and made the whole process easy and stress-free. Erin did a phenomenal job with my flowers and brought my vision to life exactly how I imagined. Jaime and Katie were by my side through my special day making sure I was good and directed the flow of the day. Everyone could not stop talking about the food. Chef Victor did an outstanding job and our guests loved the family style presentation. I am so full of joy of how everything turned out and owe it all to the staff. The grounds of Otterkill were beautiful and a great backdrop for my photos. Thank you for turning our special day into moments my husband and I will cherish forever.

May 24, 2026 was our wedding at Otterkill, and we truly could not have chosen a better venue. We visited at least five different venues throughout the Hudson Valley area, and from the very first email, Corey’s communication stood out immediately. We dealt with many venues that were not transparent with pricing or menus, and several had issues accommodating our 75–90 guest count. Otterkill completely blew every other venue out of the water. We loved the wood features, greenery, neon signs, and overall atmosphere of the venue. There were so many beautiful spaces for the ceremony, cocktail hour, and reception, and they never once gave us a problem about our guest count or requests. Corey made us feel comfortable from the beginning. He answered all of our questions thoroughly, welcomed us back multiple times to go over details, and truly worked with us before we even decided on our wedding date. Throughout the planning process, he was incredibly responsive and organized — there were even moments where he recapped my own notes better than I could have. He also recommended vendors, and the photographer he suggested ended up being one of the best decisions we made besides choosing Otterkill itself. Our guests loved the food, bartenders, and overall service. Everyone was personable and genuinely cared about making the day special. Erin one of the owners, was amazing to work with and fixed our floor plan multiple times for us. She was also there to go over things with us when we dropped off decor a couple days before our wedding. She really took the time to answer all of our questions and is a great person. Olivia, my bridal concierge, was absolutely wonderful. I had a lot going on that day and definitely did not delegate very well, but she constantly checked in to see what I needed. She was emotional support, fixed and bustled my dress multiple times, kept me hydrated, and was just such a calming presence throughout the day. My family repeatedly said they would not have been able to do it without her, and I completely agree. Jamie, our maître d’, also went above and beyond. Because of the rain, we had to adjust our entire timeline at the last minute, but the team still made my dream of getting married outside happen. They timed everything perfectly and had the ceremony set up just as the rain stopped. Jamie checked on us constantly throughout the night and handled every detail seamlessly. He coordinated with our best man and maid of honor, directed vendors and guests, and kept everything running smoothly — including things we probably do not even know about. My husband and I truly never had to worry about a thing. Our families loved him, we loved him, and we are so grateful to the entire Otterkill team for making our wedding day feel so effortless and special. We love Otterkill so much, and we are beyond happy we chose to celebrate our wedding there.

We had our wedding here two months ago and I still think about how great this venue and staff was. Everyone who worked our wedding was helpful, kind and calm. Erin and Corey were incredibly helpful during the planning process and made me feel calm during a stressful process. Erin did the whole wedding as well as the flowers and I’m so glad I trusted her because she knocked it out of the park. Jamie was attentive and was always one step ahead of me throughout the night. Katie was our maître d for the day and she was so kind and on top of everything we needed all day. We got so many compliments on the venue and the food and mostly the staff, if I get married again I will do it here lol

Just had our wedding at otterkill on Sunday and first off I want to thank Erin who made it happen. We originally had our date set for May 2025 and had to change it to a lot sooner. She was very accommodating and made sure everything was beautiful. The food was fantastic! She also did all our flowers which were stunning! We had a couple of hiccups and a few things that didn’t go as planned but overall, we are very happy and definitely recommend otterkill for any event. I want to give a huge thank you to Cali who was with us the entire day and was absolutely phenomenal! And the bartenders were awesome, everyone loved their vibe! Erin we will be reaching out to you again for future events! Thank you so much 🤍